›

›

Science & Supplements

Science & Supplements

The Ashwagandha & Rhodiola Myth: Can Adaptogens Lower Your Cortisol?

The Ashwagandha & Rhodiola Myth: Can Adaptogens Lower Your Cortisol?

|

4 min read

|

Pace & Phase Editorial

A Woman reading outside

In our fast-paced, high-stress world, the promise of an herbal pill that "cures stress and balances cortisol" sounds almost too good to be true. Herbal adaptogens—most notably Ashwagandha and Rhodiola Rosea—have exploded in popularity, marketed as natural remedies for burnout, anxiety, premenstrual moodiness, and stubborn belly fat.

While these ancient herbs have thousands of years of traditional use behind them, modern marketing often frames them as quick fixes for a lifestyle that is fundamentally out of balance.

Can adaptogens actually regulate your stress hormones, or are you better off fixing your sleep and daily fuel first?

How Adaptogens Interact With Your Nervous System

An "adaptogenic" herb is defined as a biological compound that helps modulate your Hypothalamic-Pituitary-Adrenal (HPA) axis—the central command center that controls your body’s stress response.

Instead of acting like a stimulant (which drives energy up) or a sedative (which pulls energy down), adaptogens work like a thermostat:

  • When your cortisol is spiking wildly from severe physical or emotional stress, adaptogens help buffer the rise.


  • When your system is exhausted and running on empty, adaptogens gently support baseline adrenal output.

What Clinical Research Shows

Ashwagandha (Withania somnifera)

Ashwagandha is one of the most rigorously studied adaptogens for stress. A double-blind, randomized controlled trial published in the Indian Journal of Psychological Medicine demonstrated that adults taking high-concentration Ashwagandha root extract for 60 days showed a 27.9% reduction in serum cortisol levels alongside significant reductions in perceived stress scores compared to placebo groups.

Rhodiola Rosea

While Ashwagandha is predominantly calming, Rhodiola Rosea is activating. Research published in Phytomedicine highlights that Rhodiola helps reduce mental exhaustion and cognitive burnout by supporting dopamine and serotonin availability during acute physical or mental stress.

The Catch: Why Adaptogens Won't Fix Chronic Exhaustion

Here is where the marketing myth breaks down: no herb can override a severe lifestyle deficit.

If you are sleeping 5 hours a night, skipping meals, drinking three cups of coffee on an empty stomach, and pushing through high-intensity workouts while under-fueled, your body should have high cortisol! Cortisol is simply trying to keep your blood sugar stable and keep you alive.

Taking Ashwagandha while continuing to burn the candle at both ends is like turning off your car's oil warning light while driving at 100 mph.

Furthermore, long-term continuous use of high-dose Ashwagandha can sometimes cause emotional blunting (feeling numb or flat) or thyroid hormone disruptions in sensitive individuals.

How to Use Them Responsibly

If you decide to incorporate adaptogens into your routine, follow these evidence-based guidelines:

  1. Prioritize Root Extracts: Look for standardized, clinically tested extracts (such as KSM-66 or Sensoril for Ashwagandha).

  2. Cycle Your Usage: Take adaptogens for 6 to 8 weeks during acute high-stress periods, then take a 2 to 4-week break to allow your HPA axis to recalibrate naturally.

  3. Research-Backed Dosage: Clinical trials typically utilize 300 to 600 mg of standardized Ashwagandha extract daily, or 200 to 400 mg of Rhodiola Rosea extract taken in the morning.

⚠️ Note: Adaptogens directly interact with thyroid hormones, blood pressure, and immune function. Always consult your medical doctor or healthcare professional before taking adaptogenic herbs, especially if you take thyroid medication, immunosuppressants, or are pregnant/breastfeeding.

How Pace & Phase Supports Your Nervous System

Herbs can be a helpful supporting tool, but true nervous system recovery requires systemic balance. Pace & Phase helps you monitor your daily stress inputs, sleep hygiene, and training loads across every phase of your cycle—giving you the insights you need to calm your nervous system naturally and permanently.

Key Vocabulary


Adaptogens: A unique class of non-toxic herbs and mushrooms that help your nervous system adapt to physical and emotional stress by buffering cortisol swings.

Ashwagandha: A traditionally calming adaptogenic root herb known for dampening overactive stress signals, lowering nighttime cortisol, and supporting peaceful sleep.

Rhodiola Rosea: An activating, invigorating adaptogenic herb that helps sharpen mental focus, clear fatigue, and support dopamine during acute burnout.

HPA Axis (Hypothalamic-Pituitary-Adrenal Axis): The master hormonal communication loop between your brain and adrenal glands that controls your fight-or-flight stress response.

Cortisol Regulation: The process of keeping stress hormone output balanced so your body doesn't stay trapped in a state of high alarm, water retention, and sleep disruption.

Stop guessing. Start navigating your metabolism.
Join the waitlist for 50% off at launch.

Start navigating your metabolism.
Join the waitlist for 50% off



Stop guessing. Start navigating your metabolism.
Join the waitlist for 50% off at launch.



Frequenly Asked Questions

Q: Does ashwagandha actually lower cortisol?
A: A double-blind randomized trial cited in the article found that adults taking high-concentration ashwagandha root extract for 60 days had a 27.9% reduction in serum cortisol alongside lower perceived stress than the placebo group. That said, the article stresses that no herb can override a severe lifestyle deficit like chronic sleep deprivation or under-fueling.

Q: What is the difference between ashwagandha and rhodiola?
A: Ashwagandha is predominantly calming, while rhodiola is activating. Research highlighted in the article shows rhodiola helps reduce mental exhaustion and cognitive burnout by supporting dopamine and serotonin availability during acute physical or mental stress.

Q: Can I take ashwagandha every day without a break?
A: The article recommends cycling adaptogens: 6 to 8 weeks during acute high-stress periods, followed by a 2 to 4-week break so your HPA axis can recalibrate. It also notes that long-term continuous use of high-dose ashwagandha can sometimes cause emotional blunting or thyroid hormone disruptions in sensitive individuals.

Q: Will adaptogens help if I am exhausted from poor sleep and diet?
A: No. The article is blunt on this point: if you sleep five hours a night, skip meals, and push through hard workouts under-fueled, your cortisol is high for a reason and an herb will not fix the underlying deficit. Look for standardized root extracts like KSM-66 or Sensoril, use clinical-range doses, and talk to your doctor first, especially with thyroid medication, immunosuppressants, or pregnancy.

Founding member offer

JOIN THE WAITLIST

and get our FREE 4-week high-protein menu instantly

Stop guessing. Start navigating your metabolism.
Get 50% off for life, no credit card required

You'll land on the download page right after signing up.

Founding member offer

JOIN THE WAITLIST

and get our FREE 4-week
high-protein menu instantly

Stop guessing. Start navigating your metabolism. Get 50% off for life, no credit card required

You'll land on the download page right after signing up.

Founding member offer

JOIN THE WAITLIST

and get our FREE
4-week high-protein menu instantly

Stop guessing. Start navigating your metabolism.
Get 50% off for life, no credit card required

You'll land on the download page right after signing up.

Pace and Phase Instagram icon
Pace and Phase Facebook icon
Pace and Phase X social icon

© 2026 Pace and Phase

  • Pace and Phase fitness image showing feet walking on a treadmill
  • Pace and Phase fitness image of a woman in black activewear
  • Pace and Phase fitness image of a woman carrying a yoga mat outdoors
  • Pace and Phase mobility image of a woman stretching
  • Pace and Phase recovery image of a woman using a foam roller
  • Pace and Phase fitness image of runners moving outdoors
  • Pace and Phase community portrait of two active women
Pace and Phase Instagram icon
Pace and Phase Facebook icon
Pace and Phase X social icon

© 2026 Pace and Phase

  • Pace and Phase fitness image showing feet walking on a treadmill
  • Pace and Phase fitness image of a woman carrying a yoga mat outdoors
  • Pace and Phase mobility image of a woman stretching
  • Pace and Phase recovery image of a woman using a foam roller
  • Pace and Phase fitness image of runners moving outdoors
  • Pace and Phase community portrait of two active women

Physiology-aware training
& nutrition for women

Pace and Phase Instagram icon
Pace and Phase Facebook icon
Pace and Phase X social icon

© 2026 Pace and Phase

  • Pace and Phase fitness image showing feet walking on a treadmill
  • Pace and Phase fitness image of a woman in black activewear
  • Pace and Phase mobility image of a woman stretching
  • Pace and Phase recovery image of a woman using a foam roller
  • Pace and Phase fitness image of runners moving outdoors
  • Pace and Phase community portrait of two active women